Guthrie Real Estate Search

Guthrie Properties between $450,000 and $500,000 for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for between $450,000 and $500,000 properties available in Guthrie and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Guthrie real estate market? Sign up for a  Guthrie Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Guthrie Properties between $450,000 and $500,000 for Sale

$499,900
3 Beds 3 Baths 1246109 MLS
Set on just over an acre in the Deer Creek School District, this beautifully appointed home offers an exceptional blend of space, comfort, and thoughtful design, with expansive front and back yards framed by mature trees. A flexible study or formal dining room with French doors welcomes you just off the entry, while the main living room features a raised ceiling and windows overlooking the serene backyard. Open to the living area, the remodeled kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, showcasing granite countertops, a tumbled marble backsplash, gas range with pot filler, built-in microwave, full-size refrigerator and freezer, and a spacious dining area. A butler’s pantry and separate walk-in pantry provide exceptional storage and added functionality. The impressive primary suite, added in 2016, creates a private retreat with a fireplace, beamed ceiling, generous walk-in closet, and a spa-inspired bathroom featuring a double vanity, oversized soaking tub, and separate walk-in shower. With the laundry room just off the primary it is equally spacious and offers abundant built-in cabinetry and storage. Two additional bedrooms are positioned on the opposite side of the home, including a second en suite bedroom. An additional flexible space could be perfect for a large walk-in closet or has the versatility of a fourth bedroom, or an additional living area. A hall bath conveniently serves the third bedroom and guests. Outdoor living is equally impressive with an oversized covered patio featuring a built-in gas fire pit and outdoor kitchen with grill, plus an open patio area just off the primary suite. The expansive backyard offers a peaceful setting with mature trees and two detached buildings, a workshop with garage door access and a separate storage building.

11416 Wolf Creek Road, Guthrie

$499,640
5 Beds 3 Baths 1248366 MLS
This Hazel Bonus Room 5 Bedroom has 2,735 Sqft of total living space, which includes 2,520 Sqft of indoor living space and 215 Sqft of outdoor living space. This two-story luxury home offers 5 bedrooms, 3 full baths, 2 covered patios, a spacious bonus room, a large utility room featuring a utility sink and deco tile flooring, and a 3-car garage with an in-ground storm shelter installed. The living room presents a stacked stone corner gas fireplace, a 3-panel sliding door with a 4’ back patio extension, wood-look tile, Cat6 wiring, rocker switches throughout, and an impeccable coffered ceiling with a ceiling fan and crown molding. The kitchen supports stainless steel appliances, including a 5-burner cooktop and double ovens, custom-built cabinets to the ceiling with cabinet hardware and under cabinet lighting, 3 CM countertops, stunning pendant lighting, a large corner pantry, modern tile backsplash, and an oversized island with a built-in trash can pullout. The primary suite offers a sloped ceiling with a ceiling fan, windows, and our cozy carpet finish. The prime bath features a dual sink vanity with framed mirrors, a free-standing tub, a walk-in shower, a private water closet, and a HUGE walk-in closet. Covered outdoor living boasts a wood-burning fireplace, a gas line for your grill, and a TV hookup for your flatscreen. This home also offers our healthy home technology, a tankless water heater, a whole home air filtration system, R-44 insulation, and more!

545 Straight Street, Guthrie

$489,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 1238382 MLS
This gorgeous new construction home captures the essence of modern craftsman design, blending rustic charm with contemporary sophistication. High vaulted ceilings with striking rustic beams create a grand sense of openness, while large picture windows fill the home with natural light and frame peaceful, rolling views. Perfect for hosting, the living room is centered around a gorgeous fireplace, which flows effortlessly into the gourmet kitchen. This culinary masterpiece features a large island with hidden storage, built-in stainless steel appliances, and a huge pantry for ultimate organization. Wood-look tile flooring adds warmth and durability throughout. The master suite is a retreat, showcasing rustic ceiling beams, a walk-in closet with built-in dressers, and direct access to the utility room. The spa-inspired bath offers double vanities, a modern soaker tub, and a sleek doorless walk-in shower. Three additional oversized guest bedrooms each feature spacious walk-in closets, and an additional bathroom with shower/tub combo lots of storage. Plenty of room for outdoor living and recreation with an oversized patio, already prepped for hookup to your gas grill. Additional highlights include 8-foot doors and a community that is shop approved. Car enthusiasts will love this three car garage, perfect for vehicles, hobbies, or storage. Perfectly located just 30 minutes from Edmond and Oklahoma City, and 45 minutes from TAFB. This exceptional home is where timeless design meets luxurious comfort in Guthrie’s scenic countryside.

4380 Janie Way, Guthrie

$476,340
4 Beds 3 Baths 1246292 MLS
This Shiloh Bonus Room floor plan includes 2,805 Sqft of total living space, which features 2,450 Sqft of indoor living space and 355 Sqft of outdoor living space. There is also a 610 Sqft, three-car garage with an in-ground storm shelter installed. This defining home offers 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, 2 covered patios, a utility room, a mini blind back door, and a large bonus room. The spacious living room features a stunning coffered ceiling with crown molding and a ceiling fan, a stacked stone surround center gas fireplace, wood-look tile, large 7’ windows, rocker switches throughout, and Cat6 wiring. The high-end kitchen supports custom-built cabinets to the ceiling with glass and lights in the uppers, under cabinet lighting, and cabinet hardware throughout, impressive tile backsplash, built-in stainless-steel appliances, a center island equipped with a trash can pullout, impeccable pendant lighting, a walk-in pantry, and 3 CM countertops. The primary suite offers a sloped ceiling detail, windows, a ceiling fan, our cozy carpet finish, and 2 separate walk-in closets. The attached primary bath features separate vanities with framed mirrors, 3 CM countertops, a free-standing tub, a private water closet, and a huge walk-in shower. Secondary bedrooms feature high ceilings with a ceiling fan, carpeted flooring, windows, and sizeable closets. Property is fully sodded with an in-ground sprinkler system in both yards! The covered back patio offers perfection with its wood-burning fireplace, gas line, and TV hookup. Other amenities include Healthy Home technology, a tankless water heater, a whole home air filtration system, R-44 Insulation, and more!

601 Straight Street, Guthrie

$475,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 1245042 MLS
Open House this Saturday and Sunday, 10:00-6:00. Welcome to Regado Ranch in the highly desirable Cashion school district—where modern comfort meets peaceful acreage living. Just completed new construction! Builder is offering $5,000 toward closing costs or upgrades of your choice. Situated on over 1 acre, this stunning single-level home offers approx. 2,346 square feet with 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, a separate study and a side-entry 3-car garage. From the moment you arrive, the amazing curb appeal and front door set the tone for what’s inside. Step into a bright, open layout featuring beautiful wood floors throughout the main living areas and a show-stopping vaulted cathedral ceiling with exposed beams in the living room. Large windows flood the space with natural light and provide picturesque views of the expansive backyard. The kitchen is designed for both function and style, complete with a spacious walk-in pantry, ample cabinetry, and a seamless flow into the living and dining areas—perfect for entertaining. A well-appointed mudroom adds everyday convenience, while thoughtful custom features can be found throughout the home. Enjoy the benefits of country living with well water, a tankless hot water system, and plenty of room to create your ideal outdoor space. Located on a brand-new asphalt road (Forrest Hills Rd), this home offers a quiet setting with easy access to Highway 74 and a quick drive to Oklahoma City, shopping, dining, and more.

9560 Regado Court, Guthrie

$475,600
3 Beds 3 Baths 1244118 MLS
Welcome to this gorgeous home nestled on a serene one-acre lot in Guthrie, OK, within the Cashion School District and just 14 minutes from the new shopping and dining development near NW 178th & N Portland. This home offers the perfect blend of peaceful surroundings, thoughtful design, and convenient access to everyday amenities. Inside, the spacious open-concept living area flows into the kitchen and there is a designated dining space. Beautiful, stained beam work and mantle adds character to the living room, while the kitchen features creamy cabinetry, a stained island and vent hood, quartz countertops, and gold lighting and hardware. The walk-in pantry offers abundant storage, plus dedicated counterspace and an outlet—ideal for small appliances or creating a tucked-away coffee station. The primary suite features a comfortable carpeted bedroom and a beautiful bathroom with dual vanities and a freestanding tub. The spacious walk-in closet is designed for organization with a built-in shoe rack and dresser. Additional bedrooms are positioned around a Jack-and-Jill bathroom with dual vanities, while a convenient powder bathroom serves the main living areas for guests. Outside, the front porch and covered back patio provide inviting spaces to relax and take in the peaceful one-acre setting. Patio fans add comfort for enjoying the outdoors, while the sprinkler system makes maintaining the property a breeze. A beautiful home with room to breathe, stylish finishes, and a peaceful setting—while still keeping you close to shopping, dining, and major conveniences.

9027 Avington Way, Guthrie

$479,900
4 Beds 4 Baths 1243977 MLS
**Builder is offering $10,000 incentive towards upgrades, closing costs or rate buy-down!** This gorgeous new construction home captures the essence of modern craftsman design, blending rustic charm with contemporary sophistication. High vaulted ceilings with striking rustic beams create a grand sense of openness, while large picture windows fill the home with natural light and frame peaceful, rolling views. Perfect for hosting the living room is centered around a marble-tiled fireplace, which flows effortlessly into the gourmet kitchen. This culinary masterpiece features a large island with hidden storage, built-in stainless steel appliances, and a huge butler’s pantry for ultimate organization. Wood-look tile flooring adds warmth and durability throughout. The master suite is a retreat, showcasing rustic ceiling beams, a walk-in closet with built-in dressers, and direct access to the utility room. The spa-inspired bath offers double vanities, a modern soaker tub, and a sleek doorless walk-in shower. Oversized secondary bedrooms each feature spacious walk-in closets, with a hotel-style Jack and Jill bath tiled to the ceiling for a refined finish. Plenty of room for outdoor living and recreation with an oversized patio, already prepped for hookup to your gas grill. Additional highlights include 8-foot doors, a spacious mudroom, and the community that is shop approved. Car enthusiasts will love this three car garage, perfect for vehicles, hobbies, or storage. Perfectly located just 30 minutes from Edmond and Oklahoma City, and 45 minutes from TAFB. This exceptional home is where timeless design meets luxurious comfort in Guthrie’s scenic countryside.

4449 Raymond Lane, Guthrie

$475,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 1242937 MLS
A RARE OPPORTUNITY ON BEAUTIFUL LAKE GUTHRIE Experience the charm of lakefront living in this one-of-a-kind home overlooking Lake Guthrie. Built in the 1930s as a hunting & fishing cabin, owned by the same family since 1957. Filled w/ treasured memories & timeless character, ready for its next chapter. On 1.13 acres, the home offers breathtaking views. The main living, dining &kitchen boast many original finishings, including chinked log construction & architectural details, wood-burning fireplace, warm wood walls, beadboard ceilings & handcrafted finishes that reflect its rich history. Expanded over the years, it combines vintage charm w/ generous living space & endless potential to make it your own. Additions in the early 70's include a spacious wing including a primary suite, 3 additional bedrooms, a full bath & laundry/craft room. A large family room, flex room & attached two-car garage were added in the 80's AND in the 90's, SOON TO BE YOUR FAVORITE SPOT, a light & bright front sunroom w/ amazing lake views. A versatile 5th bedroom just off the living is ideal as a home office, craft room, playroom or guest suite. The possibilities are endless! Storage is abundant with two attic spaces, a small basement, the original garage & extensive built-in cabinetry. The back is perfect for entertaining, featuring a basketball court, the original stone picnic table & prep area plus a charming stone outbuilding for flexible living space or storage. Recent improvements: a NEW CLASS 4 ROOF & decking(2023), all ext windows(2022), & fresh ext paint (2025). Additional amenities: Central HVAC, rural water, well for sprinkler, aerobic septic, & in-ground storm shelter. Located in one of Lake Guthrie area’s most desirable neighborhoods, five miles south of historic Guthrie & 15 minutes from Edmond, this property offers peaceful lake living w/easy access to city amenities. Don’t miss your opportunity to live on the lake in this unique property! Schedule your private tour today!

1016 N Shore Drive, Guthrie

$455,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 1232710 MLS
CUL-DE-SAC LIVING ON NEARLY AN ACRE + 3-CAR GARAGE + SHOP-APPROVED NEIGHBORHOOD + 4 BEDROOMS/3 FULL BATHS + FLEXIBLE GUEST/MULTIGENERATIONAL LAYOUT + $10K YOUR WAY! This one gives you room to live a little bigger! Tucked into a quiet cul-de-sac in Thelma Place, this NEO Home pairs wide-open Oklahoma living with designer finishes, incredible storage, and a floor plan designed to do more. Step inside to a show-stopping living room where soaring vaulted ceilings, expansive windows, and a statement fireplace create a bright, dramatic space that immediately feels like home. The kitchen holds its own with an oversized gathering island, abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, walk-in pantry, and effortless flow into the dining and living areas. Thoughtful storage is tucked throughout the home, giving everything a place without sacrificing style. The private primary suite offers a true retreat with large windows, a gorgeously designed spa like bathroom, and a large walk-in closet. While the secondary bedrooms deliver exceptional flexibility with a Jack-and-Jill bath plus a separate fourth bedroom near another full bath, perfect for guests, a home office, or multigenerational living. Outside, nearly an acre gives you room for a future pool, garden, play space, backyard gatherings, or the shop you've been dreaming about in this shop-approved community. The oversized 3-car garage with stained concrete floors adds even more usable space for vehicles, storage, tools, toys, or weekend projects. With convenient access to Guthrie, Edmond and I-35, suddenly the difference is clear! More land. More flexibility. More storage. More possibilities. Go ahead, take up some space, you’ve earned it!

10925 Sandstone Ridge Way, Guthrie

$456,690
4 Beds 3 Baths 1225149 MLS
This Sage Bonus Room 1 floor plan includes 2,550 Sqft of total living space, which includes 2,300 Sqft of indoor living space and 250 Sqft of outdoor living space. There's also a 625 Sq Ft, three car garage with an in-ground storm shelter installed. This home offers 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, 2 covered patios, a utility room, and a bonus room. The living room features an outstanding cathedral ceiling with crows feet and a ceiling fan, a beautiful fireplace with our stacked stone surround detail, large windows, rocker switches throughout, Cat6 wiring, and wood-look tile. The kitchen has decorative tile backsplash, built-in stainless-steel appliances, well-crafted cabinets to the ceiling with under cabinet lighting and cabinet hardware installed throughout, pendant lighting, 3 CM countertops, a corner pantry featuring a glass pantry door, and a large center island equipped with a trash can pullout, sink, and dishwasher. The primary suite boasts an extraordinary, sloped ceiling detail with a ceiling fan, sizeable windows, and our cozy carpet finish. The attached spa-like primary bath features a dual sink vanity with framed mirrors, 3 CM countertops, a European walk-in shower, a free-standing tub, a private water closet, and an incredible walk-in closet that will leave you speechless. The covered back patio offers a wood burning fireplace, a TV hookup, and a gas line. This home also features healthy home technology, a fresh air ventilation system, a tankless water heater, and so much more!

645 Straight Street, Guthrie

$480,900
3 Beds 3 Baths 1217307 MLS
1-ACRE LIFESTYLE PROPERTY UNDER $500K!! This home offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and space, situated on over one acre of beautifully maintained property. Featuring three spacious bedrooms, two-and-a-half baths, a dedicated study/workout room or nursery, and an unfinished attic area inside the home for extra storage , this home is thoughtfully designed for both everyday living and entertaining. Step inside to soaring ceilings, walls of windows, and an abundance of natural light throughout. Oversized custom Pella sliding doors seamlessly connect indoor and outdoor living spaces. The striking fireplace serves as a dramatic focal point , complemented by beautiful designer lighting throughout the home. The chef's kitchen is truly the heart of the home, showcasing an oversized island, gas range, walk-in-pantry, and designer built-in-bar complete with wine rack - ideal for hosting gatherings in style. The private primary suite offers a luxurious retreat with double vanities, a beautifully tiled shower, and an enormous walk-in closet. Secondary bedrooms , generously sized to accommodate family or guests comfortably. Enjoy outdoor living year-round on the covered patio featuring a cozy fireplace, plus a separate fire pit area overlooking the expansive backyard. With exceptional design details, abundant natural light, and room to roam both insides and out, this property is a rare find. DON'T MISS OUT ON THIS BEAUTIFUL CUSTOM HOME, BOOK YOUR PRIVATE SHOWING TODAY!!!

2600 Hayfield Way, Guthrie

Start Your Search

Copyright © 2026 MLSOK, Inc. This information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed. Subject to verification by all parties. The listing information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is copyrighted and may not be transmitted, retransmitted, copied, framed, repurposed, or altered in any way for any other site, individual and/or purpose without the express written permission of MLSOK, Inc. Information last updated on .